• 2024-06-16

Kioxia Struggling Major Shareholder's IPO Debuts

In a significant development reminiscent of the high-stakes world of private equity and technology, Japanese semiconductor manufacturer Kioxia is making strides towards its initial public offering (IPO). According to insiders, Kioxia has set a preliminary price range of 1,390 to 1,520 yen per share, aiming to raise a total of approximately 70 billion yen through this public listing. However, for its primary shareholder, Bain Capital, navigating these waters presents a complex challenge. The low return on investments coupled with Kioxia's substantial debt could deter potential investors from partaking in this offering.

The story of Kioxia's acquisition is as tumultuous as it is fascinating. Back in 2018, Bain Capital, in collaboration with prominent players such as Apple and South Korea’s SK Hynix, orchestrated a leveraged buyout of Toshiba's memory chip unit for a staggering 2 trillion yen (around 18 billion USD at the time), following the latter's scandal-ridden past. This transaction was hailed as a milestone in the history of corporate development within Japan, given its size, complexity, and the strong opposition from the Japanese government regarding foreign control over strategic technology. Bain Capital, however, successfully secured the deal, an outcome that was far from guaranteed given the political and financial hurdles involved.

Advertisement

The current ownership structure of Kioxia is a blend of Bain Capital-led investors and Toshiba, with the former holding approximately 56% of the shares while Toshiba retains about 41%. An important aspect of the impending IPO is the intention from both Bain Capital and Toshiba to gradually reduce their stakes once Kioxia successfully lists. This reduction strategy seeks to extract some financial returns amid the looming uncertainties included within the semiconductor market.

However, the situation surrounding the IPO is not without its complications. Bain Capital and Toshiba anticipate that the shares to be sold during the IPO would incur losses, excluding dividends or any associated fees. This realization perhaps adds a sense of urgency to the listing process. Regardless of the immediate monetary prospects, successfully executing this transaction is crucial for Bain Capital to uphold its reputation within the fiercely competitive private equity arena globally.

As part of the IPO strategy, Kioxia plans to issue 21.6 million new shares. Calculating based on the midpoint of the prescribed offering price, this could yield about 31.4 billion yen. Additionally, Toshiba and Bain Capital’s BCPE Pangea fund are also projected to sell a total of 50.4 million shares, valued at 73.3 billion yen, at the same price point. The company is expected to launch its stocks on December 18, marking a moment of anticipation and potentially critical consumer interest.

The tumultuous journey leading to the IPO has provided its fair share of difficulties. The cyclic nature of the semiconductor industry previously thwarted Kioxia's IPO attempts back in 2020, and a proposed merger with Western Digital met resistance last year, primarily due to SK Hynix's objections. Reports have surfaced suggesting that Bain Capital had been preparing to reignite the IPO discussions months prior but encountered valuation disagreements with global investors, leading to further postponements.

As they re-engage with the IPO plan, daunted by previous setbacks, Kioxia's projected market valuation, based on the IPO's indicative price midpoint, stands at around 784 billion yen (approximately 5.23 billion USD). This figure starkly falls short of the acquisition price from six years ago and is even 20% lower than the proceeds Toshiba recorded from its sale. Moreover, this valuation represents only half of the 1.5 trillion yen valuation Bain had aspired to a few months prior. Economic data indicates that as of June, Kioxia's stock was valued at 1.5 times its book value, lagging behind competitors like SK Hynix, Western Digital, and Micron Technology.

The implications of Kioxia's financial struggles are significant, with the company facing an uphill battle due to its towering net debt of 1.2 trillion yen as of June, which is 14 times the adjusted EBITDA expected by the end of the fiscal year in March 2024. Fortunately, a recent rise in storage chip prices has revitalized Kioxia's growth trajectory, offering a sliver of hope amid a tumultuous landscape.

Despite this recent positive turn, the burden of debt repayment remains a formidable challenge for Kioxia. The ongoing competition in the semiconductor arena is fierce, with rivals pouring substantial amounts of capital into research and development of new technologies, as well as into the construction of state-of-the-art manufacturing facilities. Analysts like Nicolas Baratte highlight that over the course of the past three and a half years, Kioxia has significantly underinvested in capital expenditures, allocating only 27% of its revenue for re-investment, a stark contrast to its primary competitors who average 37%.

This situation depicts a cautionary tale of how the semiconductor industry, characterized by volatility and rapid innovation, continues to be a sector where financial acumen and strategic foresight are paramount. As Kioxia navigates the IPO process and the financial intricacies accompanying it, the actions taken now will not only determine the company’s immediate fortunes but could redefine its trajectory within the ever-evolving tech landscape.

The stakes are high, but if Kioxia manages to successfully transition into a publicly listed company, it may pave the road for renewed investor confidence and operational investment. In turn, this move could either signal a robust comeback for Kioxia or further complicate the challenges ahead as the company seeks to balance the intricate dance of public market expectations with operational realities.

Comment