The financial landscape of Hainan Yedao (Hong Kong Stock Exchange code 600238.SH) has captured the attention of many investors recently. Following a robust surge in stock prices on December 2nd, the company’s fortunes are being scrutinized amid promising developments surrounding the Hainan Free Trade Port initiatives. The upcoming promotional event, scheduled for December 4th at the Blue Hall, which centers on “Local Practices of Chinese-Style Modernization: New Missions and Opportunities at Hainan Free Trade Port”, has sparked enthusiasm for the Hainan sector. This may potentially lead to invigorated investment opportunities for stakeholders.

However, the pivotal question remains whether Hainan Yedao can capitalize on this perceived 'golden opportunity.' The company's financial reports from the first three quarters reveal a mixed bag: a revenue of 163 million yuan, up by a modest 0.15% from the previous year, alongside a significant net loss of over 10 million yuan. These figures seem insufficient to instill confidence in its immediate future.

In an effort to reverse its declining fortunes, Hainan Yedao rolled out an “Enhancing Quality and Efficiency for Returns” strategy on November 27th, focusing on the main business developments. The aim includes upgrading their product offerings, optimizing product structure, improving market distribution, and enhancing overall governance effectiveness. Despite these efforts, attempts to secure an interview for deeper insights have been met with silence from the company’s representatives.

Advertisement

Industry analyst Cai Xuefei remarks that while there have been incremental improvements in performance over recent years, the root challenges persist. The corporate structure has been plagued by protracted and complex ownership disputes, resulting in diseconomies of scale and a profit squeeze. Such operational inefficiencies appear to be an impediment to the company's progress.

Adding to the company’s challenges, Hainan Yedao has faced the specter of delisting. Since 2021, the company has logged losses for three consecutive years. According to the new delisting regulations, if Hainan Yedao cannot turn a profit or its revenue dips below 300 million yuan, it may face dire consequences—including potentially being delisted from the stock exchange.

In a bid to preserve this corporate entity, the Haikou State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission stepped in to take control of Hainan Yedao in June 2023, undergoing a leadership revamp with Duan Shouqi being appointed as chairman. This transition marks a significant historical shift for Hainan Yedao, which had been under the influence of various private investors and ownership structures since 2015.

Food researcher Zhu Danpeng points out that the multiple waves of controlling stakeholders led to frequent strategic realignments, leaving the management team struggling for direction and the dealer network lacking in confidence. These factors complicate the company’s ability to maintain steady growth and navigate changing market conditions.

Nonetheless, Cai is optimistic about the potential for state-owned capital intervention to enhance the company’s credibility. He believes that the presence of state-owned investors can bolster brand integrity and stimulate product sales, creating a more stable corporate ecology that will enable Hainan Yedao to concentrate its resources and streamline operations towards recovery.

This newfound state oversight appears to have improved the company's performance in the early quarters of the year, with reports indicating a return to profitability for the first time in recent memory. However, the third quarter of 2023 reflected a setback, showing revenues of 41.75 million yuan, a 7.71% decline year-over-year, and the overall loss for the first three quarters remained concerning.

The decrease in revenue the company attributed much to typhoon damage that hindered its production capabilities and assets, combined with the unsatisfactory launch and subsequent sales of new products, which were unable to meet projections and ultimately impacted profitability adversely. Without sufficient gross profit to cover operational costs, the outcome was negative for the quarter.

Amid these trials, Hainan Yedao is committed to focusing on its core business—herbal liquor. Their strategic plan unveiled on November 27 emphasizes the goal of enhancing the operational quality of its primary offerings. The management has outlined a vision to fortify core business growth and bolster overall profitability, targeting specific areas for expansion and investment.

Hainan Yedao's recent endeavors have seen it investing in Guizhou-based liquor enterprises, entering new markets focused on herbal-flavored liquors and healthcare products. This is a significant shift towards crafting niche offerings that resonate with current consumer trends towards health and wellness. The collaboration with Guizhou Guoma Distillery aims to create herbal liquor that will redefine Hainan’s alcohol production landscape.

Moreover, Hainan Yedao established another venture with the Renhuai City Hutu Distillery in Guizhou, thus expanding its foothold in the sauce liquor market. Despite these strategic moves, recent figures suggest that revenues from the traditional liquor segment have not kept pace, showcasing only 31.45 million yuan in earnings from their entire liquor portfolio during the current year.

In light of this stagnation, management has acknowledged the lack of immediate profitability in the broader liquor market, framing their strategy around collaborations with established distillers who possess superior resources while retaining focus on their own successful segments like health-oriented drinks. The developmental trajectory of the liquor business since its revamping indicates that Hainan Yedao remains dedicated to its health liquor model, with ongoing efforts to stabilize and grow its market presence.

Cai’s analysis suggests that the health-focused liquor sector is limited in size, which poses a challenge to Hainan Yedao’s broader strategy. The company’s growth in traditional liquor market segments has not been a historical strength, and introducing novel products in these highly competitive bond areas requires patience and astuteness to foster brand value and consumer recognition. He advocates that a targeted, practical approach to investment is imperative to avoid dilution of essential resources and ensure sustainable operations moving forward.

Amid the evolving market dynamics, Zhu concurs with Cai’s assessment, emphasizing that the primary focus should remain on solidifying the health liquor line before pursuing other ventures. The path forward may be fraught with obstacles, but with prudence and strategic focus, Hainan Yedao may yet revitalize its operations and regain its status in the spirits market.